Student who challenged Michele Bachmann to a debate gets threats, tea party scoffs

Google GmailFacebookTwitterLinkedInStumbleUponRedditFarkDiggTumblrBlogger PostDeliciousFriendFeedNewsVineGoogle BookmarksGoogle ReaderMultiplyPosterousEmailBookmark/FavoritesWordPressShare

Cherry Hill High School East sophomore Amy Myers, who criticized Rep. Michele Bachmann, said comments on conservative websites have her worried. / Photo: ALEXANDRA ELISABETTA


As you may recall, a very bright and apparently knowledgeable teenager, a high school sophomore to be exact, challenged a very dim and fact-challenged Michele Bachmann to a Constitution-off– a “Public Forum Debate and/or Fact Test on The Constitution of the United States, United States History and United States Civics,” to be exact.

And what did she get for that? Serious concerns for her own safety. Amy Myers and her father, Wayne, became alarmed at comments they were reading on conservative websites.

Via the CourierPostOnline:

A lot of them are calling me a whore,” 16-year-old Amy Myers said, referring to anonymous comments [...]

Several commenters threatened to publish the Myers’ home address. Others threatened violence, including rape, they said.

Myers, a single dad, sounded panicked, according to the report:

“I got a call from the principal that the main office received threatening mail… I personally did not think there would be a reaction like actual stalking and the vitriol that’s coming out.”

Of course, the tea party was compassionate, concerned, caring… Or to put it another way, they showed utter disrespect, and they even took a shot at Amy and her father. William Haney, founder of the West Jersey Tea Party:

I certainly would be interested in seeing those threats rather than taking the word of a parent,” he said.

I find it exceedingly difficult to believe that anybody who is associated with Michele Bachmann would be threatening Amy.”

So to recap, the official position of the West Jersey Tea Party is to exhibit blatant asshatitude by scoffing at vile name calling and threats to a teenaged girl, implying that her father is a liar, and challenging their overall credibility– not to mention disregarding the Myers’ feelings– all because it’s way more important to prop up a pea-brained crackpot’s wobbly reputation.

Conservative “family values” strike again.

More here.

UPDATE, here are a few comments under the Courier piece. Now Mr. Tea Bagger can see for himself:

BEAN0

5:28 AM on May 20, 2011

HOO RAY FOR DAD……INSTEAD OF USING HIS OWN AGENDA, HE HAS NOW DRAGGED HIS EASILY INFLUENCED DAUGHTER INTO THINKING SOMEONE HAS HER ON A HIT LIST…….SOMETIMES CHERRY HILL PEOPLE THINK THEIR FECIES DON’T STINK! YOUR DADDY IS PUSHING YOU TO AN ARENA WHERE YOU ARE CONVEYING HIS THOUGHTS…….GO DO YOUR HOMEWORK SCHOOLGIRL!

UpOnThings

7:39 AM on May 20, 2011

This is news? Come on Jane! How do you expect people to respect you when you become an enabler for nut cases and nut cases using their kids to get attention.

Eulenspiegel

9:47 AM on May 20, 2011

Little Amy Myers is learning at an early age just how mean and dirty politics are. Back to the student council and algebra problems, Amy.

From Amy’s father:

WayneMyers

12:23 PM on May 20, 2011

I am Amy’s father.

After reading this article, and probably not reading the original articles at City Pages & Yahoo, several seem to be posting many false beliefs and accusations about my daughter’s actions or mine. It hasn’t yet escalated to calling her names and the like, but after seeing some of these posts… it won’t be long.

I was a register Republican who voted for Reagan, Perot, GHWB, Clinton the second time, NEVER for GWB and then Obama. On a state level, I never voted for a Democratic governor – including voting for Christine Whitman and Chris Christie. I voted for the late John Adler this past time, but voted for Chris Myers the time before that. I fought against Corzine’s plan to monotize the toll roads. It is true that I donated $250 to President Obama’s 2008 campaign and registered myself as a Democrat. I did it in an attempt to get Obama could win the NJ Primaries. I don’t know if I can switch back to being an Undeclared voter or not. I vote split ticket – for the best candidate. I am not a party shill and no one party owns me. I have a mind and I pass free and critical thinking skills onto my children.

My daughter’s actions were her own. Her writing of the letter was her choice. As a parent, I wholly support my daughter. Amy is in Honor’s English, AP History as a sophomore and was appointed Op-Ed for the CHHSE newspaper. You should really see her articles; two at Yahoo’s Lookout site. You should then read her City Pages articles before you continue to throw accusations and cast your politically influenced comments.

As an Independent who leans to the right, (making only 3 democrat votes in my life), I am rather disgusted in my former party – the Original party of Reagan back in 1980, before the Moral Majority and Libertarians gained control. It is true. If Reagan was in the New GOP, he’s be run out on the rails. To see my former party followers write such filth about a child is simply disgusting – This includes the Sean Hannity Forum!

More comments:

CornRowdMoFo

5:24 PM on May 20, 2011

A women’s place is in the House-
Between a Man and a Bed!

WayneMyers

6:09 PM on May 20, 2011

@CornRowdMoFo “A women’s place is in the House- between a Man and a Bed!”

And the sad part is, at least one person faved it.

Google GmailFacebookTwitterLinkedInStumbleUponRedditFarkDiggTumblrBlogger PostDeliciousFriendFeedNewsVineGoogle BookmarksGoogle ReaderMultiplyPosterousEmailBookmark/FavoritesWordPressShare
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Photographs on The Political Carnival:
Please read our policy on images from non-TPC sources in the sidebar to your right.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

  • Rick_winter

    If you are a Republican, you are a jerk, as the above comments prove.  Homo sapiens?  Probably.  Human?  Not in the slightest!

  • Libsrone

    To Amy and her father – I want to give you my full support. I live in MN although not in Bachmann’s district. The amount of misinformation the spews from this woman’s mouth is very disturbing. Her supporters are not the least bit concerned with facts. Amy, I encourage you to fulfill your passion for politics. When my optimism wanes, it is stories like yours that build it up again. You go, girl!!!

  • Rhodaozen

    I do hope the police find who are making these comments involving rape and physical violence. These are not posts that are First Amendment issues they are illegal threats of violence aimed at a minor. They’re punishable by law and it’s quite simple to get these posters IP and arrest them at their homes.
    Bachmann sits back and allows such egregious implied violence to occur but what if it were one of her children?
    Amy I give you credit for your honesty, brains and bravery. You need help post here and I’ll see it, I live within 45 minutes of you, I’m from Bucks County, Yardley and am surrounded by these types of cowards.
    At 16 I was fighting fir a woman’s right to choice, for Title IX and equality in the job market so anyone that says at 16 you haven’t made up your own mind and try to blame your great Father for you making this decision don’t understand the intellect of a 16 year old woman!
    Got your back girl, ring and I’ll be there to help you organize.

  • http://www.facebook.com/AtomicShaman Atomick Shaman

    The Tea Party is composed largely of aggressive, feeble minded, authoritarian crap-cakes. Is it any surprise that they respond with such vitriol to child who dares challenge their equally feeble minded demi-goddess?

  • http://www.facebook.com/AtomicShaman Atomick Shaman

    The Tea Party is composed largely of aggressive, feeble minded, authoritarian crap-cakes. Is it any surprise that they respond with such vitriol to child who dares challenge their equally feeble minded demi-goddess?

  • http://www.facebook.com/pages/Maureen-ODanu/193281680703022 Maureen O’Danu

     What kind of solution is that? Because the assholes are out there, she needs to lock herself up? How ’bout we lock up the assholes instead? (metaphorically speaking). Those were threats.  Legally, that’s quite possibly assault. 

    No. Just no.  If she cages herself, they win.  It’s a tactic called silencing, and it has been used against activists for years.  She needs to stand loud and proud and denounce her attackers and call them out for what they are. And Michele Bachman needs to denounce them as well.  And the newspapers and blogs and other places where these threats are being posted needs to pull them. That’s how civil society works.

    Threats are not free speech in any society.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=696459521 Zuhayr Jamal

     She shouldn’t be reading the comments. If she doesn’t read them then they wont harm her and she can live her life without fear.

  • FawcettUniverse

     @WayneMyers – just remember that every person here who’s posted insults at your daughter is an illiterate idiot who has their heads shoved up Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity’s bums, and if Bachmann (sounds like a Nazi to me) is anything like Arizona governor Jan “Asshat” Brewer, who actually had her people post a picture of Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords with a target stamped on it, she NEEDS to be impeached and prosecuted.

  • Irasciblelad

    Sick of it. Sick of it all.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/David-Starkey/1131310367 David Starkey

    by the way, ‘uponthings’ seems to think that 16 year olds can’t form their own opinions.
    Maybe not in HIS family.
    In mine, I started watching convention coverage at age 11 in 1968.
    I have been UP ON THINGS ever since.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/David-Starkey/1131310367 David Starkey

    Ask for volunteer guards.
    In Texas, we have concealed handgun licenses.  We also have a law against “Criminal Mischief in the Nighttime”.  If someone comes on your property after dark and causes damage, or shouts threats, or does anything criminal, YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO SHOOT TO KILL.  Now, I’m not suggesting that you necessarily DO so, but having a fact like that to cover your butt makes it a LOT easier to sleep at night. 
    I live in Dallas, or I’d volunteer for some shifts myself.

  • Wiley

     As a fiscal conservative and someone who looks at things from a realistic viewpoint. The Tea Party as we see it today is NOT what it was intended to be. It has become an angry mob of disgruntled social conservatives who do not really believe in freedom or liberty. Believe me, I have been to Tea Party rallies and talked to some of them. They have no clue on what is killing this country (wars, Federal Reserve, corporate controlled politicians, military industrial complex) they have become a bunch of blind, FOX watching idiots and it is sad to see. The original Tea Party movement promoted freedom and liberty for all with small government being the issue. It was a Libertarian movement started by Ron Paul supporters. Then FOX latched onto it and made it something it was NOT intended to be. FOX has supported big government neoconservatives and social conservatives. And in my opinion, social conservatism is just another form of fascism. Bachmann couldn’t debate her way out of a paper bag and I guess her supporters feel threatened by a 16 year old girl who is probably ten times smarter than her.  SAD day in America.

  • Mikegatliff

    These threats remind me of the politics of Germany in the 1930′s. If you spoke out aganist the state or a certain party you were singled out and destroyed. The GOP and Tea Party speak of family values yet threaten familys with laws that hurt familys.    A quote that was made in 1933 that fits todays times. “The merger of the State and Corporations is the definition of Fascism”. The quote was made by Adolf Hitler  

  • Mikegatliff

    These threats remind me of the politics of Germany in the 1930′s. If you spoke out aganist the state or a certain party you were singled out and destroyed. The GOP and Tea Party speak of family values yet threaten familys with laws that hurt familys.    A quote that was made in 1933 that fits todays times. “The merger of the State and Corporations is the definition of Fascism”. The quote was made by Adolf Hitler  

  • Fogdiver117

    Amy Myers should run for President one day. Just saying.  

  • Anonymous

     The Republican Party has transformed itself into the party of pure authoritarianism with a special emphasis on destroying any example of independent thought,  and it has become focused on delivering swift retribution for whomever dares not toe the party line.  There is no room for growth.  There is only room for rehashing the same failed policies by repackaging them and promoting them as new and unique ideas.  Anything that doesn’t grow, dies.  It can be either a slow, or a quick ,death, and I’m beginning to think that after the election of Obama, the party has chosen the quick route.  

    I’m a retired high school teacher, and I love to see kids like Amy Myers excel because kids like these are our future.  I also have a strong aversion to seeing grown behind folks attacking a kid because he/she is young but alert enough to notice when politicians’ knowledge and behavior don’t match their rhetoric.  She was right to call Bachmann out for the uninformed individual she is.  When I read about Amy’s challenge to Bachmann, my heart sang, and I was filled with pride as if she were my own child.  I taught civics, world history, economics, and U.S. History for over 30 years, and I am always offended when republicans distort our history, tell lies about our economy and economic policy, and  abuse their power as members of Congress.  If Bachmann is so formidable and so knowledgeable, taking Amy on should be a cakewalk, and she shouldn’t need anyone affiliated with the GOP to run interference for her.  She can put up or shut up.  If she doesn’t respond to Amy’s challenge and continues to allow her nut brigade to harass her, she is  just another money-making blowhard know nothing carrying water for the  Republican Party.    

  • http://twitter.com/sean_mason sean_mason

     Sadly that’s a common reaction to comments on that newspaper’s website, it’s not representative of the residents of South Jersey, just the ones who have nothing better to do than troll message boards (and I have my doubts how many actually live in South Jersey).

  • http://www.facebook.com/pages/Maureen-ODanu/193281680703022 Maureen O’Danu

    As a feminist and liberal who has been on the web a long time, none of it surprises me. Sickens me, yes, but surprises me, no.  I wish the best of everything to Amy and her father.

  • KansasDem

    This “is” who the Tea Party really is!

    Think about their very first “action” ………….. sending hundreds of tea-bags to various offices in DC.

    The effing dummies had no clue that “action” involved man-hours billed to taxpayers.

    The Tea Party is actually non-existent! It’s a collaboration of the most extreme elements of the Republican party!

  • http://www.hispanicaffairs.info Jorge

     I read the comments and they made me angry and sick. 

  • http://twitter.com/sean_mason sean_mason

    The comments on the Courier Post story are equally vile; blaming the father or the girl for daring to express a liberal opinion, suggesting he/she is lying about the whole thing, suggesting she should have just shut up and not tried to correct Bachmann, etc… This is not surprising; the Courier Post is a right-wing newspaper that almost exclusively endorses Republicans for local office and the comments section on the articles is a cesspool of right-wing hate. Then again I’ve found that comments sections on newspapers, whether they’re liberal or conservative, tend to devolve into right-wing echo chambers where reasonable people are afraid to enter.

  • http://twitter.com/sean_mason sean_mason

    The comments on the Courier Post story are equally vile; blaming the father or the girl for daring to express a liberal opinion, suggesting he/she is lying about the whole thing, suggesting she should have just shut up and not tried to correct Bachmann, etc… This is not surprising; the Courier Post is a right-wing newspaper that almost exclusively endorses Republicans for local office and the comments section on the articles is a cesspool of right-wing hate. Then again I’ve found that comments sections on newspapers, whether they’re liberal or conservative, tend to devolve into right-wing echo chambers where reasonable people are afraid to enter.

  • Anonymous

     Good old Christian family values of the republicans.  Amen!