"It is not the pro-gay rights position that has been reduced to absurdity, it is Scalia himself."

FacebookTwitterRedditDiggStumbleUponTumblrLinkedInPinterestEmailShare

scalia marriage equality gay

Today's L.A. Times letters to the editor, because our voices matter:

Re "The 'animus' of Justice Scalia," Editorial, Dec. 13

Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia's argument is, as you say, "abstract and not terribly helpful," but it is anything but logical.

Scalia commits the fallacy of false analogy. In the case of murder, it is not mere disapproval that grounds the law; murder directly harms other individuals and society, so the state must use its power to protect its citizens. Homosexuality and same-sex marriage are private, self-regarding behaviors that do not harm others in any material way. Hence, anti-gay laws rest on mere disapproval (animus), which cannot be a legitimate reason for intruding on individual liberty.

The irony of Scalia browbeating that law student for not appreciating his "logic" is almost too much to bear. It is not the pro-gay rights position that has been reduced to absurdity, it is Scalia himself.

James S. Stramel

Los Angeles

***

Scalia would make being "morally reprehensible" sufficient justification for deciding whether a law violates the Constitution. Strange, but I cannot find that phrase anywhere in the document itself. Perhaps Scalia can find it in the minds of those who wrote the Constitution, which he claims to be able to read.

The important judicial question in this case is whether being morally reprehensible is also sufficient justification for removing a Supreme Court justice.

Angus Andrews

Westlake Village

FacebookTwitterRedditDiggStumbleUponTumblrLinkedInPinterestEmailShare
  • http://twitter.com/whatsamatta_u Paul W

    Yet he seems peachy keen to approve Citizens United, which causes far-reaching material harm to untold millions of people. While Marriage equality directly pumps up the local economy - florists, caterers, print-shops, bridal gown makers, musicians, gazebo architects, restaurants, hotels & churches  ;D