Walmart segregates books based on race

Bob Dyer has a terrific post up at the Beacon Journal’s Ohio.com. Please read all of it, but here’s the gist:

Walmart is segregating their book displays. They have all their black books here, and all their white books over there.

And by black, I mean those written by or about those ::whispered:: dark-skinned people. And by white, I mean anything by or about those whom the Walmart Biggies apparently prefer. God forbid the bindings should intermingle or the covers touch. EW!

I wonder how their lunch counters are arranged…

The ”black section” contains everything written by and about blacks: romance novels, self-help books, religion, sports, even an autobiography by the current president of the United States.

Now, whether or not you’re a fan of Barack Obama, can’t we at least agree that the thing that defines him is not his skin color but his job title? [...]

At the Walmart in Montrose, Storm Warning, by hugely popular white pastor Billy Graham, can be found in the religion section. But Life Overflowing, by hugely popular black pastor T.D. Jakes, is in the black section, along with Dungy and Obama and Sister Souljah and Adrienne Byrd and all those other people whom Walmart believes are pretty much the same.

The positioning of books within the black shelves would be laughable if it weren’t such a sorry commentary on Walmart’s thought process — or lack thereof. For instance, directly beneath a faith book by gospel artist Kirk Franklin is a steamy novel called The Hot Box, whose back cover promises ”fiery titillation.” [...]

When asked why many of its stores have a ”black section” that lumps together everyone from romance novelists to preachers to the president of the United States — even though they have little in common beside skin color — Wal-Mart Stores Inc. responded without really responding.

To find out what they said, follow the link. Hint: It’s all about the money.

Yeah, um, no.

I’ve heard of racy books, but this takes the cake. Sorry, had to joke or my head would explode, I’m just that appalled.

Now I have one more reason to continue to avoid that place. I’ll be here, and they can stay over there.

H/t: cherveny

  • Jjcristal

    This is a practice that's been going on for years, and it's supported by Black publishing groups and author organizations. Black authors have seen their sales numbers go up, and drastically, since Walmart started using those shelves. More Black authors have been getting published because of this. If a Black woman wants to help her teenage daughter find positive role models in fiction, she knows exactly where to look for a book like that.

    Walmart carries Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man, Toni Morrison's Beloved, and Nell Painter's Creating Black Americans: African-American History and Its Meanings, 1619 to the Present. Walmart carries these books because it pays off for Walmart to carry these books, so long as they're not buried with dissimilar books. Having that shelf leads to a better informed, more aware group of readers.

    Invisible Man and Beloved are serious literature. Walmart doesn't carry much serious literature, but it carries those.

    So yeah, it's Walmart, and the people who buy those books give money to Walmart, so that's bad. But having these books visible and available helps Black authors, their publishing houses, and the Black community, especially its young people.

    If people here want to find something to get upset about in the race/publishing nexus, you might want to read up on what happened to the cover of Cindy Pon's book _Silver Phoenix_.”

  • Jjcristal

    GotttaLaf, I went to my local urban Walmart to find out, but first I stopped at the Border's next door. I was the only white person there. There was an entire wall of black american fiction and about a dozen people were standing in that section. But when I went to the regular fiction section, not only wasn't Toni Morrison there (or any other black authors), neither were any customers.
    I then went to the Walmart “book department” and it's only about 15 feet of shelf space tucked into a little corner with NO categories. And the books were mostly written by black authors. Didn't bother me that there weren't many (of any) white authors represented.
    This is called retail merchandising, not race.
    And if you see my post above, you may not like Wal-Mart, but the company has increased dramatically black author sales.

  • guest

    GotttaLaf, I went to my local urban Walmart to find out, but first I stopped at the Border's next door. I was the only white person there. There was an entire wall of black american fiction and about a dozen people were standing in that section. But when I went to the regular fiction section, not only wasn't Toni Morrison there (or any other black authors), neither were any customers.
    I then went to the Walmart “book department” and it's only about 15 feet of shelf space tucked into a little corner with NO categories. And the books were mostly written by black authors. Didn't bother me that there weren't many (of any) white authors represented.
    This is called retail merchandising, not race.
    And if you see my post above, you may not like Wal-Mart, but the company has increased dramatically black author sales. The black publishing industry loves Wal-Mart. And if a black urban woman is looking for a positive role model for her daughter, sho knows just where to go.

  • Jjcristal

    There is no story here. Wal mart has been doing this for years and Black publishing organizations love it because they have seen a dramatic increase in Black author sales. A woman in an urban neighborhood who wants to find a role model for her daughter can head straight to this section. Walmart also carries some very intellectualized black authors when none of its other books are as deep. Further, I don't know where this journalist was shopping, but my local urban Wal-Mart has no “sections.” Just about 15 shelf space of mostly black authors. And the Borders next store had a huge black literature section, but I didn't even see Toni Morrison represented in the general literature section. The hundreds of black people in that store didn't seem to mind.

  • Pedro

    Some Historically Black Colleges do it, too. Take a look at Huston-Tillotson’s library catalog, and see where the books about President Obama are shelved.

    http://library.htu.edu/cgi-bin/Pwebrecon.cgi?DB=local&PAGE=First

  • Pedro

    Some Historically Black Colleges do it, too. Take a look at Huston-Tillotson’s library catalog, and see where the books about President Obama are shelved.

    http://library.htu.edu/cgi-bin/Pwebrecon.cgi?DB=local&PAGE=First

  • NORMA63

    I shopped at walmart (notice, not capitalized) until I saw their book section…….I think this is DISGRACEFUL . ADD TO THIS THE FACT THAT….. they discriminate against women also…..fighting a class action suit because they pay women less……if they handle it on a one on one basis they can frighten an individual woman into dropping the suit…. a class action will cost them much more…..The lawyers may get most of it but wALMART WILL PAY MUCH MORE……DONE WITH SHOPPING AT wALMART……..

  • Mangleman

    Another Example of a MANUFACTURED Controversy! Sorry, I LIKE seeing these authors on display! It alerts me to any new offerings and allows me to easily support a new author! Besides, aren't many Bookstores equipped with Ethnic sections?? W.T.H??

  • Jonah247365

    In 2008, when both of Obama's books were on all the BEST SELLERS LISTS, where were his books at my local Walmart? No, not in the best sellers section, but in the black literature section. Ahem, maybe it should have been both?? Just sayin…. I don't think I've even set foot in a Walmart since 2008 anyhow. Avoid it like head lice.

  • Huda

    I somewhat agree with bcsusmc75, other stores that aren't real bookstores like Target also do it. However, as Ms. Gottalaff stated the difference is there is one little table for certain black authors in most book stores, but I've never seen or heard of a whole list of authors divided by their skin color. The issue here is, white authors are left on what is termed 'mainstream' headings, while black authors despite the genre are delegated into 'colored' corner.

    I remember on Indigo and Chapter in Canada, the store tried the 'black authors' sections, but without delegating all black authors just in one location. It pissed ppl off and they had to remove it.

  • lsamsa

    Hmmm, so if I'm browsing for a fiction novel…I would have to search both the 'black' authors' section & then the 'other colour' authors' section…have I got that right? Or is there yet another section for 'yellow' & possibly for 'brown'? Or does it go by nationality as well, as in African American, Japanese Canadian…well, I'm getting silly…why would Wally Mart carry anything by Japanese Canadians!

    Good grief…no not a big deal compared to the toilet spin the U.S. is in…but heck, it's a start to try to be somewhat colour-blind with things where it really doesn't matter.

  • http://thepoliticalcarnival.net/ GottaLaff

    I know what you're saying, bc, but after reading the whole article and what

    books were included, how they were sorted, it made no real sense. Alan

    Colmes just crossposted this piece after he saw my post, and he was

    outraged, and it's getting retweeted like crazy. This post hit a nerve with

    a lot of people, including me.

    This doesn't seem at all minuscule to me, but I get your point.

  • bcsusmc75

    And I'll say it again, most bookstores do the same thing, it's called categorizing literature. Go to any big box bookstore and you'll probably find a section for African American literature. I agree there is racism in this country and it's a damn shame, but this is really reaching. I respect your opinion, but this seems to be a kneejerk reaction triggered by the racial climate of this country. We are so on edge, we thing even the most miniscule thing is racist and that in itself is part of the problem.

  • http://thepoliticalcarnival.net/ GottaLaff

    Yeah, no biggie. In fact, it's getting a huge reaction on Twitter, because

    apparently, the story hasn't been out there. It's one thing to say, yeah

    yeah, they've been doing it for years, and another to call them out.

    If you dig a little deeper, the segregation is real. There is no reason to

    separate the books the way they have, per the author of the article.

    But hey, move along, nothing to see here.

  • Tyroanee

    Blows that alphabetical thingy out the window… just yet another reason I have never, nor will I shop at a BIG BOX chain.
    Buy Local or quit whining.

  • bcsusmc75

    P.S. – Don't get me wrong, there is a lot to go after Walmart over, but this just doesn't seem that big of a deal to me. Now if they refused to sell black literature altogether, that would be a whole other issue.

  • bcsusmc75

    Wow, somebody is a little late with this story; Walmart has been doing this for years. They aren't the only ones either, Target and other book retailers do it too. I'm not sure this anything to get riled up about either, but that's just my opinion.