Getting answers from the Obama administration is not easy

If you recall, Jerrold Nadler and James Oberstar sent a letter to the EPA and the Department of Labor about the use of dispersants and other toxic agents.

Now Ed Markey is giving it a go with a letter to the FDA:

The entire letter can be seen here. For all my posts about the dangers of dispersants, please go here, including this one from a few minutes ago.

It’s somewhat reassuring to see members of Congress jumping all over this. I say somewhat, because real reassurance will come with real answers and real solutions.

Here is an excerpt from the Nadler/Oberstar letter:

“There are several hazardous substances present in the oil and in the chemical dispersants that are supposed to break up the oil, forming a ‘toxic soup.’  The dispersant that BP has chosen to use, Corexit, is considered one of the most toxic.  Last week, several cleanup workers were taken to the hospital complaining of nausea, shortness of breath and other respiratory ailments,” said Oberstar.  “It is the federal government’s responsibility to enforce public health and safety laws.  Unfortunately, at the World Trade Center following the 9/11 terrorist attack, OSHA rules were not enforced, and thousands of emergency responders, area workers and residents are now sick and receiving treatment.  This must not happen to those living and working in the Gulf Coast area.”

There have been so many concerns, so many questions, and yet there seems to be a reluctance to respond. I’m not sure what to make of that, but at least some of these should be answered sooner than later. What’s the hold up?

It may be nothing (according to Hugh Kaufman, a senior policy analyst at the EPA’s office of solid waste and emergency response, that’s doubtful) , but even the appearance of reticence or a lack of transparency isn’t exactly the best way to go these days… or any days.

  • Anon

    OSHA is just one more federal job. A federal job is employment that is guranteed as long as you do as little as you can, make no decisions, have no thoughts of your own, and do ONLY what you are told. Keep your mouth shut, and if you are told to cleanse your ass after defecation by wiping in a horizontal (rather than vertival) motion, you will do just that. Some people seem more adapted to these type jobs than others, but if you meet the qualifications (as mentioned above) you will be rewarded with life-long employment.By the way, OSHA will not respond to direct phone calls reporting drunken heavy equipment (cranes) operators inside chemical plants, as I can attest to from 20 years ago. OSHA is the biggest joke on the construction site; may be why they don't show up often. When they do make an appearance, it is after several days' advance notice. Can't we ALL just get a government job and be happy? I certainly don't see why not.

  • barkway

    My best guess would be that BP somehow has a stranglehold (or an inside man) on OHSA, NIOSH, and perhaps even the EPA. There is NO excuse for these agencies sitting silently by while thousands of people are exposed to the toxins that surely are involved anywhere this oil spill has had an impact. Corexit alone is KNOWN as a neurotoxin and in the amounts it has been used for this event (more than ever anywhere in history), it can't help but have severe health effects for those exposed.

    On OHSA's own web site, they proudly crow about their air and water monitoring along the Gulf, assuring everyone that all is safe and no out of the ordinary levels of exposure have been detected when everyone with eyes and ears KNOWS that's not true. Just the other day, there were reports on several major networks of marine workers having parts per billion of toxins in their systems that exceeded the allowable levels according to OHSA's OWN standards. OHSA and NIOSH should be ashamed of whatever it is that BP has said or done to them or for them to make them stand down while thousands suffer and will surely suffer more in larger numbers as this tragedy unfolds. And WHERE is Adm Thad Allen in all this? Isn't he the voice of the People via his assignment by our government leaders as the head of the Deepwater Horizon Response? Is he aware that BP has now ordered all cleanup workers' pay cut? And that this isn't the first such order? That they will no longer pay per diems or provide housing? How many HAZ certified workers do they think live in each of the counties impacted (that don't need housing because they happen to live there). We all know the so-called “training” they are giving those they hire from amon the unskilled nad uncertified does NOT meet the 40 hr hazwoper standard as set forth by OHSA (or maybe OHSA doesn't care?). How long does the government expect us to wait for them to “grow a pair” and DO something about all this fraud, lies, mismanagement,disregard for public health, abuse of workers, abuse of Gulf residents, etc, etc.

  • http://twitter.com/jkarsh Jason Karsh

    I hate to say it, but I think it's all murky because the administration is letting BP run this show and BP's focus is on recovering as much of this oil as they can and making whatever they can't appear non-existant. BP doesn't care about this coastline or this ecosystem. To their minds, that's not their job. It's the administration that needs to hold BP's feet to the fire on that stuff and they're not doing a very good job of it. So they're slow to answer questions because they'd rather not admit it. Just my guess, though.

  • Merry A. Kogut

    I prefer no indents on these block! paragraphs. Otherwise, I'm behind the letters 100%!